Left Continue shopping
Your Order

You have no items in your cart

Orders Can Be Placed Until Sunday at 11:59PM for Thursday Delivery or Pickup.

Butter Tart: Salted Caramel 6-Pack


Carla's Cookie Box is best known for her gooey, award-winning butter tarts. Featured at many farmers markets around the city, these gourmet butter tarts are handmade using local Ontario ingredients.

Carla loves to get creative and have fun with her flavours. These flaky crusted butter tarts have a smooth butter tart filling, but are amped up with a pool of salty caramel on top.  

Package includes 6 butter tarts. 

Having a hard time choosing flavours? These tarts freeze well, so you can buy more than one flavour pack. But they might not make it to the freezer... 

Customer Reviews

Based on 2 reviews
Laurie M.
Best butter tart

Been searching for the perfect butter tart and this is it, plain or warmed with ice cream 😋

Michelle L.
Out of this world

Biting into this butter tart was like time stopping; the mad world disappeared and nothing mattered but what was happening with your tastebuds. It was like heaven. Reaching a higher plane. I've never had a butter tart so darn good. That salted caramel on top; I couldn't speak, I just savoured. Unreal.