Left Continue shopping
Your Order

You have no items in your cart

Thank you for your continued support! We are currently not accepting online orders.

PB&J Cookie Pie


Heirloom's dessert creativity is abound again! Their homemade chewy cookie with Belgian chocolate, toffee & pretzels is baked into a pie shape, and stuffed with peanut butter, homemade jam & crunchy graham cookies. Delight your friends with this pie, of treat yourself on a cheat day!

Scratch-made with local diary and quality ingredients.

This item comes freshly baked and freezes well, so you can stash some for later! 

Customer Reviews

Based on 2 reviews
Valerie L.
Ordered twice and already thinking of the next one

This pb&j cookie is decadent, fresh and tastes amazing! It has a bit of salt and crunch from the peanut butter and of course the homemade jam to tie it all together. Will order again. Will also order the banana one again.

Sylvie T.

This is pure indulgence! The whole family devoured it in no time and we were all licking our fingers.!!! The combination of ingredients is soooo good! We will definitely get it again.